I was covering for the medicine service at the Ann Arbor VA Hospital 1 weekend in 19 75. I had been there only a few weeks, and the FBI was swarming the building seemingly in the aftermath of a serial killer who had been injecting patients with a paralyzing agent-pavulon. Conditions had quietened, and the Federal agents were gone, and so we thought was the serial killer. An unusual feature of the VA Hospital was that weekend coverage for the entire hospital was the responsibility of a single intern and medical student. Now it was my turn. Saturday morning and afternoon were quiet, and I was hoping for a silent night. Unfortunately, at 10:00 p.m. the alarm sounded and the student and I were summoned emergently to a patient’s room, where we found him on the floor vomiting huge quantities of bright red blood. This was before the days of fiber optic GI scopes, but that would not have mattered anyway. The patient had obviously ruptured either esophageal varices or broken loose an arterial stomach or duodenal ulcer bleed on a massive scale. I managed to get an IV in his arm but before we could even transport him to the MICU or start IV fluids he had a total collapse and cardiac standstill. The student looked at me and said, ” Aren’t we going to pump him?” by which he meant start cardiopulmonary resuscitation and chest compressions. I looked at the scene and replied'” Pump what? It’s all on the floor!” There was nothing we could do.
Blood circulation is normally a closed system, but in the case above, that system was open. When examined closely, our circulatory system is predicated on exact fluid hemodynamics. The components include the physical properties of blood, the diameters and flexibility of blood vessels and the heart wall, cardiac valves, pressure waves and fluid linear flow/ turbulence, and the stroke volume of the heart. Not to mention that all of this is irrelevant if we do not have functioning lungs, kidneys, bone marrow and other anatomic systems. Problems that can arise with our circulatory system medically are numerous and include formation of blood clots, vessel tears, atherosclerosis with vessel narrowing, loss of elasticity, rapidity of heart rate, and malfunction of heart valves just to name some. We have been created with precise physiologic and anatomic parameters to ensure a steady supply of oxygen and nutrients to distant tissues while removing waste products. The degree of perfection in the system is truly awe inspiring.
We need to realize there are two circulatory circuits: 1 that circulates blood through the lungs to provide oxygenation, and the other to circulate this oxygenated blood through the entire body ( I am not including the fetal circulatory system during pregnancy which is an entirely different order of complexity).Since the circulation in the lung is a low pressure system, the right side of the heart (which is responsible for this) does not need to be as strong as the left side. Accordingly, the right heart musculature is not as thick and does not have to produce high pressure. In fact, high pressure in the lungs in disease states is quite detrimental. There are two valves on the right side of the heart, in exactly the right place to ensure continuation of steady flow through the lungs in 1 direction. These valves are highly specified. I have difficulty conceiving a scenario whereby blind natural selection mediated by haphazard mutations results in a perfectly sized right heart configuration and perfectly placed valves.
The left side of the heart receiving the oxygenated blood similarly has two valves-the mitral separating the small atrial chamber from the large left ventricle, and the aortic valve at the site of blood exiting as the left ventricle contracts strongly. This contraction has to produce enough pressure to drive blood throughout the body. The left ventricle stroke volume is such that in a healthy heart 55-60% of the blood is expelled. The heart valves have to be perfectly configured, with just the right pliability. The aortic valve has 3 leaflets. Occasionally, a birth defect results in only two leaflets, but this produces an abnormally directed jet of blood which causes abnormal stress on the aortic wall–the large artery that receives the blood from the left side of the heart. Not only can this damage the aortic wall and increase the risk of dissecting the aorta, but can also damage and rupture blood cells themselves, also leading to premature calcification and stiffening of the valve. What I am saying is that the valves are perfectly sculpted, perfectly designed, perfectly placed in the only location where they would be effective. And life depends on this. To believe that nature’s blind stumbling in the dark produced such a Master Piece borders on lunacy.
Not only do the machine like mechanics of the heart have to be perfect, but so does the timing of the heart’s contractions. Our internal pacemaker-the sinus node-is only a few sq mm in size, but sparks regularly at a general rate of 1 per second. Too slow, and the heart is not going to eject enough blood into the systemic circulation to allow much ability to be active. I have been called to the emergency room to urgently place a temporary pacemaker and essentially speed up the heart rate–the results can be dramatic. Watching a heart rate soar from an incapacitating 20 beats per minute to 60 beats per minute once the lead line is connected to the battery can allow a nearly unconscious person to suddenly start talking and moving normally. On the other side of the equation, if the heart is racing the left sided chambers do not have adequate time to fill, and the ability to function normally is distorted. Under emergency situations, cardioversion with the electric paddles may be needed to restore normal heart rate. The frequency of our internal pacemaker firing is perfectly timed.
Our life second to second depends on the precise functioning of this sinoatrial node (SAN), so what is the backup plan for a breakdown of the apparatus? isn’t it kind of important to maintain the heartbeat? Amazingly this tiny group of bioelectrical cells that are so critical to maintaining life have fail safe backups plans. Indeed there are multiple independent clusters of these cells, such that if 1 group malfunctions, the others continue on. It’s like having multiple light switches for a bulb. There are also multiple nerve pathways from the SAN to propagate the nerve impulse and cause the small chambers (atria) to continue to contract if 1 pathway is blocked or malfunctions.
If the SAN does completely fail, there is an additional backup system. Further down the electrical pathway towards the large chambers is the atrioventricular node (AVN). This is a relay station to conduct the electrical impulse into the large chambers (ventricles) and cause these to contract. The AVN is also tiny– measuring 1x3x5 mm, basically a computer chip in our heart. This is a beautifully designed electrical circuit, since the current needs to be briefly delayed to allow completion of the small chamber contraction before the large chambers contract. Disorders of the atrial electrical system can sometimes cause tachyarrhythmias, wherein the heart rate can increase dramatically to over 200 beats per minute. The AV node can block impulses if too rapid, maintaining a reasonably effective ( albeit elevated) heart rate. And as the ultimate backup system to potential failure of the SAN, the AVN can take over the pacemaker function, causing the heartbeat to originate from that location. This is electrical engineering at the highest level. There is no conceivable way that natural selection/random mutation could result in such an exquisitely arranged system.
Once Blood is ejected from the left ventricle it enters the aorta- the large artery that conducts blood throughout the body. This artery must with stand the pressure wave striking it, and be flexible enough to smooth out the liquid tidal force. At this stage we are dealing with such fluid engineering problems as laminar flow, shear effect, turbulence, fluid viscosity, and helicity/ swirling currents. All of these will affect the volume of blood transported to the tissues and potential damage to arterial walls and to the blood cells themselves. Abnormal blood clots may occur as adverse fluid dynamics develop and aneurysms may develop wherein vessel walls are thinned to the point of rupture. Various organ systems may be starved of oxygen enriched blood. In essence, our circulatory system- which includes blood flow through our lungs, then passing through the heart which pumps it, the condition of our downstream blood vessels, and the composition/ physical properties of our blood -all that must be as close to perfect as possible. Problems continuously arise and to counteract these, redundancy and fail safe mechanisms have been built into this system along with the ability to actually repair damaged structures and reroute flow when interruptions arise. None of this happened due to unguided random materialistic good luck with no more backing in reality than is found in a Chinese fortune cookie. A system this sophisticated and resilient had to be planned with foresight. This is brilliant engineering, creating with biomolecules and genes rather than silicone chips and wiring.
The 1st exit ramp after blood is expelled from the left ventricle is the main coronary artery- a short ( about 1 in) critical vessel that leads to the branching arteries that supply the heart muscle. The positioning and angle of this vessel are significant– modeling studies show slight alteration of these parameters can dramatically effect the volume of blood entering the coronary circulation, as well as increasing the shear stress on vessel walls that can result in future damage. The heart is so hard working that it extracts 70-80% of the oxygen supplied to its musculature verses 30-40% extracted by skeletal muscles. We definitely want the heart’s blood vessels to be well cared for. Viscosity of the blood- basically how thick it is- also plays an important role. Blood contains formed elements such as blood cells and platelets, as well as proteins which increase viscosity. If blood is too viscous there is a higher resistance to flow and the heart will work harder. Viscosity too low results in a faster heart rate. Blood physical properties have to be just right.
The next arteries exiting from the aorta supply the brain. The cerebral arteries receive 15-20% of cardiac outflow– a significantly higher proportion than would be expected based on the weight /size of the brain. Basically the brain requires large amounts of oxygen and nutrients. Understand that the brain has no means of compelling the blood vessels to supply it with this volume of blood. The brain arises from fetal ectodermal tissue, the blood vessels come from mesoderm. They do not talk to each other or send requisition orders. The brain gets what heart and blood vessels send it and we see what happens when it gets too little– transient ischemic attacks, strokes. The blood not only provides sufficient nutrients, but is instrumental in carrying away all of those waste products produced by those heavy thoughts. Fluid accumulates in the interstitial spaces between the brain cells, and this volume has to be removed as well- speculation is that sleep is an essential timeframe for these activities to occur. Accumulation of proteins which are inadequately removed may lead to dementia. At the base of the brain is a circular arterial system– the circle of Willis- routing blood quickly around the base of the brain and supplying it to the various brain components. This circle also can modify the various hemodynamic stresses described above– turbulence, shear stress, aneurysm formation- again protecting the brain’s circulatory system. How did the circulatory architecture happen to be perfect for the organs which rely on not only receiving the exact amount of oxygen and nutrients each requires but at the same time minimizing the damage that can be inflicted by unrestrained physical impact? The plumbing systems we employee daily in our homes are far less sophisticated, yet require advance engineering and architectural planning to function. Can our circulatory system be operational with less design? I think not.
